coruLanguages

Actually, library, attend: three false friends, one meeting

Two messages from Nora could send you to the wrong place, at the wrong time, with the wrong idea. Can you recover the plan?

Actually, library, attend: three false friends, one meeting
Actually, library, attend: three false friends, one meeting Image credit: Coru. Original Coru title cover; DejaVu font.

4:10 p.m. Your coat is already on the chair.

In this invented scene, you have arranged to meet Nora at 5 p.m. Coffee can wait: you check your phone before leaving. Two messages arrive.

Nora, 4:10 p.m.: “I’m at the library. I’ll attend the talk at five.”

Nora, 4:11 p.m.: “Actually, let’s meet outside the library at six.”

If you speak French, you probably recognise nearly every word. That is the trap: three look familiar enough to make you reply without reading again. Before you go downstairs, work out the place, the meeting time and what Nora plans to do at five.

What is the plan?

Choose an answer in your head while reading the two messages again. The explanations and answers are also available as text, without running the game.

Which reading matches both of Nora’s messages?

Answers and explanations
  • Outside the bookshop at 6 p.m.; Nora will go to a talk at 5 p.m.: The time and activity are right. But library means bibliothèque here. A French librairie is a bookshop or bookstore.
  • Outside the library at 5 p.m.; Nora will go to a talk.: You have the right place, but the second message proposes six: 6 p.m. in this scene. The original meeting time changes.
  • Outside the library at 6 p.m.; Nora will go to a talk at 5 p.m.: Yes. Library gives the place, at six the new meeting time, and attend the talk the activity planned for five.
  • Outside the library at 6 p.m.; Nora will wait for someone at 5 p.m.: The place and time are right. Attend the talk means go to the talk, not wait for someone.

Library: the right door

Nora is at the library: la bibliothèque. In this context, library does not mean the French librairie. For the shop where you buy books, use bookshop or bookstore. For the place where you read or borrow books, library works.

The final message says outside: that is where you will meet. There is no need to invent a floor, a shelf or a table. If you do not know this library, you still need its address.

Keep one limit in mind: library can also mean a collection, as in music library. The word does not always describe a building open to the public.

Attend: Nora plans to be there

“I’ll attend the talk at five” means « J’assisterai à la conférence à 17 h » here. Nora plans to be present at that event. In this sentence, attend does not mean the French attendre.

To say « Je t’attendrai dehors », you could write “I’ll wait for you outside.” Remember the small group wait for you: for connects the waiting with the person you are waiting for.

The construction matters here too. Attend to a problem means deal with that problem: s’occuper d’un problème. You cannot replace every attend with assister à without looking at what follows.

Actually: the meeting changes

Here, actually introduces a new suggestion: « Finalement, retrouvons-nous à l’extérieur de la bibliothèque à 18 h. » The word prepares you for a change; at six supplies the new time. Actually does not mean actuellement.

For actuellement or en ce moment, currently can work. In conversation, right now is also a natural way to refer to the present moment: “I’m at the library right now.”

Actually can also correct an idea or emphasise that something is true. Depending on the sentence, French translations include en fait, en réalité and vraiment. Finalement fits Nora’s change of plan; it does not fit every use of actually.

Reply without inventing the rest

Your reply can be simple: “Six works for me. See you outside the library!” — « 18 h, ça me va. À tout à l’heure à l’extérieur de la bibliothèque ! » If the place is unclear, add “Could you send me the address?”

The proposed meeting is at six and the talk at five. The messages do not say how long the talk lasts or whether Nora will stay at the library between those times. You have understood what is written; you do not need to complete her timetable.

Before your next “OK”, look for three things: the place, the time and the action. Then reread the word that seemed obvious. A false friend becomes easier to spot when you put it back in its sentence.

Sources & further reading

Leave a response